Welcome to the third blog in our series on meaningful philanthropy.
In blog one, we defined meaning and differentiated it from impactful philanthropy. In blog two, we explored how meaning can be experienced during the philanthropic giving.
Now, we'll explore why recognizing meaning is so important, and how we can discover and cultivate it alongside impact.
P15: Moments That Shape Trajectories
During Jen’s research into meaningful philanthropy, she interviewed 48 high- and ultra-high-net-worth individuals across five continents and ten time zones.
P15, a wealth inheritor, could have chosen a life anywhere, San Francisco, New York, London, the work was open to her. Instead, nine years ago, she chose to go to Mexico and become a social worker.
"There has to be a reason why I made the choice I did," she reflected. "I just knew that I wouldn't be able to live with myself if I had left them." The girls she met there were being sold into prostitution. When she saw the youngest, only nine, she simply could not leave.
This mirrors others’ reflections from the research. These meaningful moments shape meaningful trajectories for people in their philanthropy, and you can trace them from the point they started.
Why Meaning Matters More Than Success
Why is it so important to find philanthropic experiences that are not just impactful but also meaningful?
When asked if P10, another interviewee who devoted 30 years of his life in community-based nature conversation, thought he would succeed in creating his intended impact, P10 acknowledged that working in their economic environment can feel like fighting an uphill battle. Does he want to succeed? Absolutely. P10 bases all their philanthropy on the latest science in his program areas, i.e., community-based conservation. But he also noted that even if he cannot succeed, he would still be standing there because "who am I if I don't do it?"
People engaged in impactful philanthropy need figures, evidence, and impact measures. But for meaningful philanthropy, the difference is this:
People will tackle problems so hard to solve that even if they cannot succeed in their lifetime, they will still choose to engage.
Meaningful Philanthropy is not just any act of giving. The most meaningful giving experiences are not always the biggest or longest gifts. They are the gifts that fulfill what our lives stand for.
Some moments are brief; others last decades. But the philanthropic experiences that endure are those where people experience meaning for what they're born to be or what they can't live without. This is what we call the "essential self."
That is the kind of giving that the science of philanthropic psychology is uniquely positioned to create in this world.
This science, however, cannot be learned with the head alone. It must be absorbed into the heart and into one’s sense of identity in order to yield the greatest meaning for both the fundraiser and the philanthropist.
The unknown in philanthropy is why the heart needs to be involved.
The Beauty of Exploring Together
There's always a level of the unknown in philanthropy.
Exploring with care is particularly important. This care we give ourselves and others allows us to discover who we are, and this discovery is done better when we try together. That is the beauty of meaningful philanthropy, and the beauty often missed if we only work on impact or even when we try to generate meaning using only our head.
What is the gap that your life stands in, even if you can't succeed?
Part three of this four-part learning journey helps us explore these questions together.
You can sign up to this learning journey and access the full content here. It includes around four hours of learning: 155 minutes of video lectures and 85 minutes of self-guided exercises.